Which Global Hegemon Is on Shifting Sands?

Which Global Hegemon Is on Shifting Sands? (Of Two Minds, Sep 17, 2014):

Given that all the leading candidates for Global Hegemon are hastening down paths of self-destruction, perhaps there will be no global hegemon dominating the 21st century.

Which nation with aspirations of global dominance (i.e. hegemony) has these attributes?

1. The nation’s recent prosperity is based on a vast expansion of credit.

2. The nation has 100+ million obese/diabetic citizens.

3. The citizens have little say over central government policies that favor cronies.

4. The nation faces demographic headwinds as the number of people in the workforce declines and the number of retirees balloons.

5. Large regions of the nation suffer from chronic water shortages.
Hmm, sounds like the U.S. is a match so far…. Let’s add a few more attributes:

6. The nation’s credit expansion has relied on a largely unregulated shadow banking system.
7. The nation is in the midst of an unprecedented housing bubble.

This could still be the U.S., but America’s unprecedented housing bubble popped in 2006–the current bubble is a mere echo bubble. Let’s add a few more attributes:

8. The nation is beset with unprecedented “external” environmental costs as a result of rapid and largely unregulated industrialization.

9. The nation suffers from large-scale desertification.

10. Over half the nation’s monied Elites have either left the nation or plan to leave and transfer their financial wealth overseas.

The only nation with aspirations of global hegemony that fits all these attributes is China. The conventional China Story holds that the 21st century will be China’s century, much like the 20th century was America’s.

But this story overlooks the vast demographic, health, environmental and financial problems built into China’s land, people, and Central-Planning systems of finance and governance.

Consider two charts drawn from John Hampson’s recent overview of Problems in China:
China’s shadow banking system, which provided the majority of the credit that fueled the current expansion, is imploding:


Not coincidentally, China’s unprecedented housing bubble is also imploding:


China’s system allows only a limited number of options for savings and investment; other than bank accounts that have lost money when real inflation is accounted for, the primary option available to households is real estate. As a consequence, an enormous percentage of the nation’s household wealth has been sunk into empty apartments which act as “savings.”

But a physical flat in a high-rise building is not a financial asset like a savings account: it is a physical object that degrades with time and whose value is set by supply, demand and thr availability and cost of credit.

If the building is not maintained properly, elevators break down, pipes start leaking and fixtures corrode, and the value of an unmaintained building drops to zero in terms of habitability within a decade or so.

100 million apartments become an enormous mal-investment of one-time wealth as they slowly become uninhabitable due to poor construction and/or maintenance.

China has been building infrastructure at a break-neck pace for 30 years, and this has created the mindset that almost every structure will be torn down and replaced with something grander every 20 years or so.

As a result of this mindset, very few structures are maintained. Why bother if it will be torn down and replaced a few years down the road?

But tens of millions of apartments cannot replaced every decade or two.

In effect, China has squandered its one-time wealth generated by rapid industrialization, and absorbed the still-uncounted environmental and health costs of this industrialization that must be paid in shortened lives, higher healthcare costs and environmental cleanups for decades to come.

Few promoters of the China Hegemony-in-the-21st-century Story mention the estimated 114 million people in China with diabetes–over one third the population of the U.S.– or the roughly 500 million people in China with elevated blood-sugar levels that put them at risk of developing diabetes or related lifestyle diseases. China ‘Catastrophe’ Hits 114 Million as Diabetes Spreads.

How much of the nation’s surplus wealth will be devoted to fixing the environmental and health costs that are already visible? How much of the wealth is actually phantom wealththat will vanish as the housing bubble based on an unprecedented credit bubble pops?

The China Story based on demographics, health, environmental damage and financial Central Planning is a quite different one from the China will be the global hegemon in the 21st century story. Given that all the leading candidates for Global Hegemon are hastening down paths of self-destruction, perhaps there will be no global hegemon dominating the 21st century.

1 thought on “Which Global Hegemon Is on Shifting Sands?

  1. I don’t fully agree with the author, I think China will rise again due to its alliance in BRICS, China has all the technology and the blueprints of every greedy corporation looking for free labor for 25 years. Even GE gave the Chinese government their power plant blueprints, and everything. Corporations are so greedy, so short sighted, and the Chinese got all that technology for 25 years of slave labor.
    In the meantime, they continue to work with the technology, producing vehicles, computers, you name it for Russia or any nation being given fool sanctions by the west. The war from the beginning has been economic, and the US is losing badly.
    China will rise again. The US is on the edge of collapse. It is a shell, and all wealth has been stolen by the greedy guts.
    I saw this interesting story on Pompeii. There was a cellar in the home of a very rich man, and 72 bodies were found there, the cellar did indeed hold, but the people were still buried alive.
    They know who it was, the man had his seal on his finger, and the people with him were all clutching gold, jewels, everything but each other. Not one person held another…….being buried alive, their gold and greed was still more important.
    Greed is centered in pride, the key quality of the seven deadly sins. Sins as blunders, mistakes, the word sin has been hijacked by the Christians……..it meant mistakes, not black marks against one…….
    Great article. But, China will rise again, unlike the US.
    I have never seen a country anywhere in history that created enemies to keep war going……..destruction only breeds destruction.

Leave a Comment