Jul 19

Research professor Jonathan Jones says his verdict on a potato trial in Norfolk will not be influenced by his past commercial ties to Monsanto

potatoes
Anti-GM campaigners say a trial to genetically protect potatoes against blight is a waste of taxpayers’ money because a naturally produced strain already gives immunity.

The scientist in charge of a taxpayer-funded trial that may determine whether genetically modified crops will be grown in the UK has been attacked for his close links to the US biotech giant Monsanto.

Professor Jonathan Jones, head of the Sainsbury Laboratory at the John Innes Centre, the UK’s leading plant research centre, has shrugged off the controversy, insisting he has never tried to hide his business relationship with Monsanto or the GM industry.

But as the scientist overseeing the first UK trials of a GM potato, Jones has found himself at the centre of a storm after anti-GM campaigners used social networking sites such as Twitter to highlight the close links between a company he founded, Mendel Biotechnology, and Monsanto.

Mendel’s website states: “Mendel’s most important customer and collaborator for our technology business is Monsanto, the leading agricultural biotechnology company in the world.”

Jonathan Matthews, spokesman for GM Watch, which campaigns against the technology, said: “The frontman for the latest GM push in the UK is being portrayed as a dedicated public servant doing science in the public interest, but it now appears he not only has vested interests in the success of GM but even commercial connections to Monsanto.”

Helen Wallace, of GeneWatch UK, a scientific campaign group critical of Monsanto, said the US company’s “PR strategy relies on seemingly independent scientists making empty promises about the future benefits of GM crops”.

Jones made no reference to the links in an article he wrote recently for the BBC website that attacked anti-GM campaigners as “fussy eaters”. He wrote: “Some fear the domination of the seed industry by multinationals, particularly Monsanto. We need smart, sustainable, sensitive science and technology, and we need to use every tool in our toolbox, including GM.”

In a statement to the Observer, Jones insisted: “It is not true to suggest I have attempted to hide my role as co-founder and science advisory board member of Mendel Biotechnology, which has contracts with Monsanto, Bayer and BP. The information that I am co-founder… of Mendel has been in the public domain on the Mendel website for at least 10 years.” He also defended the GM trial in Norfolk, aimed at creating varieties of potato that would not need to be sprayed with fungicides to protect them from blight.

Critics claim the trial, the results of which are likely to be used to “sell” GM technology to the British public, is a waste of money because blight-resistant potatoes have already been produced through other techniques. “Given the availability of viable alternatives, the GM potato trial increasingly looks like nothing more than a PR stunt,” Matthews said.

But Jones said it would be for the government to decide whether the trial had been a success. “At the end of the trial we will be able to tell you whether the blight resistance genes we are trialling work,” Jones said. “I will not be (and do not want to be) in a position to dictate whether or not that affects UK policy towards the technology.”

Friends of Jones said that it was unfair to attack him for not stating his links to the GM industry. “If he doesn’t restate any links every time he writes a piece, that doesn’t mean he hasn’t highlighted them,” said one, pointing to the close links between the organic food lobby and anti-GM campaigners. “It is frustrating for scientists that journalists only look at scientists’ links and don’t look at other vested interests.”

Experts said there was little alternative for those researching GM crops to work with the likes of Monsanto because the Plant Breeding Institute, the public body that used to research new crops, was privatised under the Thatcher government, meaning scientists working in the field had to develop relationships with the private sector.

It has been claimed that the first GM potatoes could be available to commercial UK growers within five years, if the Norfolk trial is successful.

Jamie Doward
Sunday 18 July 2010

Source: The Observer

monsantoland

Related information:

GM food alters your DNA, changes your brain waves, destroys your immune system, your organs and makes you infertile.

- US Supreme Court Lifts Ban On Monsanto’s GM Alfalfa

- UK Academics Quit Rigged FSA Frankenfood Propaganda

- Study: Monsanto’s Roundup Kills Human Cells (Flashback)

- GMO Alert: US Attempting Global Censorship of GMO Food Labeling

- California Files Legal Brief Opposing Monsanto in US Supreme Court

- Russian Scientists Prove Genetically Modified Foods are Harmful, Suggest Ban on GM Foods

- Bayer AG admits GMO contamination out of control

- Monsanto: GM-Corn Harvest of 82,000 Hectares in South Africa Fails (!)

- Multiple Ways Monsanto is Putting Normal Seeds Out of Reach

- Monsanto’s Genetically Modified Seed Patents May Trump Antitrust Claims

- Former Managing Director of Monsanto India: Monsanto ‘Faked’ Data for Approvals

- Monsanto GM Corn Causing Organ Failure In Rats: Study (Everything You Need To Know)

- Scientist: Monsanto’s herbicide could cause brain, intestinal and heart defects in foetuses

- Hawaii: GMO taro ban proposal goes to full council

- Monsanto to Charge as Much as 42 % More for New Seeds!

- US Association of Physicians calls for Moratorium on GMO Foods

- Monsanto sues Germany over GM corn ban

- Germany bans Monsanto’s GM maize

- Greenpeace: No need for condoms – GE corn can do the job

- Austrian Government Study Confirms Genetically Modified (GM) Crops Threaten Human Fertility and Health Safety

- BIODIVERSITY: Privatisation Making Seeds Themselves Infertile

- At stake is no less than control of the world’s food supply.

- Exposed: the great GM crops myth:

“Genetic modification actually cuts the productivity of crops, an authoritative new study shows, undermining repeated claims that a switch to the controversial technology is needed to solve the growing world food crisis.”

Highly recommended videos:

- Life running out of control – Genetically Modified Organisms (!)

- The World According to Monsanto – A documentary that Americans won’t ever see. (!)

Obama and Monsanto:

- Obama Gives Key Agriculture Post to Lobbyist of CropLife America Whose Members Include Monsanto, Syngenta, DuPont and Dow Chemical

- Obama Gives ‘Pesticide Lobbyist’ Post as Chief Agricultural Negotiator

- Monsanto lobbyists to be placed in charge of food safety by Obama

On CODEX and the agenda of the elite:

- Dr. Rima E. Laibow: The Globalist Depopulation Agenda

- Dr. Rima E. Laibow on Codex Alimentarius and Food Nazification (!)

- Dr. Rima E. Laibow on the Contamination of the Food Supply & Deadly Antibiotics

- Codex Alimentarius: Population Control Under the Guise of Consumer Protection

- One Nation Under Siege – Full Theatrical Release

- Nutricide – Criminalizing Natural Health, Vitamins, and Herbs

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Leave a Reply